Star-Crossed: MLB's Biggest All-Star Snubs of 2025

Major League Baseball has revealed its All-Star rosters for both the American and National Leagues ahead of the iconic Midsummer Classic. But not every star got the recognition they deserved. Let’s take a look at the biggest snubs of this season and why they should’ve made the cut.

Juan Soto, OF, New York Mets

Courtesy of FOX Sports

It’s certainly a surprise that Queens’ newest idol didn’t make the All-Star roster. Juan Soto was left out of the National League squad, likely due to his early-season slump. However, his mid-season performance has been nothing short of elite. He was the June NL player of the month putting up .269/.399/.508 slash line with a .908 OPS, 21 home runs, and 52 RBIs ranking him 10th in all of Major League Baseball. 

However, an overcrowded National League outfield may have also played a role in Soto’s ability to make the cut. He fell outside the top six in fan-voting and wasn’t chosen as a reserve either. One of the biggest names in New York City won’t be representing in Atlanta this summer, making this an ultimate snub. 

George Springer, OF, Toronto Blue Jays

Courtesy of The Crawfish Boxes

Veteran outfielder George Springer was undeniably worthy of an All-Star nod this season, but his name was notably absent. He enjoyed a career-best resurgence this season with a 281/.374/.512 slash line, 16 home runs, 53 RBI, and 10 stolen bases over 84 games – his best all-around performance since 2022. 

Springer ranks in the top-five in nearly every major offensive category in the American League. He outperformed current All-Stars Julio Rodríguez and Steven Kwan in OPS, OBP, HRs, and RBIs, yet was left out of the roster. Despite his impressive veteran renaissance, Springer fell short in fan, player, and manager ballots. At the very least, he deserved a spot on the reserve on the American League roster. 

Spencer Torkelson, 1B, Detroit Tigers

Courtesy of Tigers

The Detroit Tigers had the chance to do something special and send five players to the Midsummer Classic, but their first baseman was snubbed. The red hot Spencer Torkelson, one of the league's best power hitters, was left out of the All-Star roster for the American League. He’s tied for the most homers among AL first basemen, surpassing 20 by the mid-season mark.

Torkelson  has had a great season with top-tier OPS at .840 and 57 RBIs. He’s the primary power hitter of the Tigers lineup, playing a pivotal role in their rise to the best record in baseball. This year, where standout first basemen are limited, Torkelson clearly stands out. In my opinion, he should have been named as a reserve behind Vlad Guerrero Jr. 

Andy Pages, OF, Los Angeles Dodgers

Courtesy of LA Times

Dodgers outfielder Andy Pages had quite the breakout season, and has been a consistent and electric contributor through the first half of the season. He’s made an impact both at the plate and in the outfield,  slashing .283/.345/.505 with 17 HRs and 54 RBIs – establishing himself as a legitimate offensive threat in an already stacked Dodgers lineup. 

Despite the remarkable season Pages is having, Fernando Tatis Jr. got the nod over him as an outfield reserve in the National League. While Pages’ numbers are greater than Tatis’ in several categories, he didn’t make the cut. In a league that often favors name recognition over rising impact, Pages’ breakout campaign deserved to be rewarded with an All-Star nod.

In a season filled with standout performances and rising stars, the 2025 All-Star roster still managed to leave several deserving names out. As fans voice their frustrations and players turn snubs into motivation, one thing remains clear: talent will always shine – whether under the bright lights of the Midsummer Classic or in the relentless grind of the second half.